FIBK First Interstate BancSystem Inc

This article identifies three bank stocks—First Interstate BancSystem (FIBK), Ladder Capital (LADR), and Truist Financial (TFC)—that are trading near 52-week highs but exhibit concerning financial metrics. The author suggests these stocks are overvalued and recommends investors exercise caution, pointing to issues like declining sales, stagnant earnings, and low profitability. The piece also briefly mentions alternative "high-quality" stocks that have shown significant returns.

Barclays has maintained an Equal-Weight recommendation for First Interstate BancSystem (FIBK). The average one-year price target for FIBK is $36.21/share, suggesting a 1.26% upside from its latest closing price. Institutional ownership data shows a slight decrease in the number of funds holding FIBK shares, though some large holders increased their positions.

Barclays has increased its price target for First Interstate BancSys (FIBK) to $38.00, maintaining an "Equal-Weight" rating. This update reflects a trend of consistent upward revisions in FIBK's price targets from various analysts, signaling growing confidence in the company's future performance. However, GuruFocus estimates the GF Value for FIBK in one year at $28.66, suggesting a potential downside despite positive analyst sentiment.

American Trust has acquired a new position of 28,570 shares in First Interstate BancSystem, Inc. (FIBK) during the second quarter, valued at approximately $823,000. Institutional investors now own 88.71% of the company, and the stock trades near $35.64 with a PE of 15.04. First Interstate BancSystem recently declared a quarterly dividend of $0.47, representing an annualized yield of 5.3%.

HoldCo Asset Management LP has significantly increased its stake in First Interstate BancSystem, Inc. (NASDAQ:FIBK) by acquiring 3,570,107 shares valued at $102.89 million in the second quarter, making it their second-largest holding. Despite this institutional buying, corporate insiders have been net sellers, offloading over 92,000 shares recently. First Interstate BancSystem currently offers a 5.3% dividend yield with a quarterly payout of $0.47, and analysts generally rate the stock as "Hold" with an average target price of $35.57.

First Interstate BancSystem (FIBK) was added to the S&P 1000 index on December 2, 2025, which could broaden its investor base. While the inclusion and recent share repurchases suggest capital flexibility, investors should remain aware of rising criticized loans. The bank's narrative projects significant revenue and earnings growth by 2028, aligning with its current fair value estimate.