Dec 30, 2025 • Finviz
BULLISH
MTG Outperforms Industry, Hits 52-Week High: How to Play the Stock
MGIC Investment Corporation (MTG) recently hit a 52-week high, outperforming its industry peers and the broader market with a 25.3% gain in the past year. The company showcases strong financial health, with shares trading above key moving averages, affordable valuations, and a favorable return on invested capital. Analysts are optimistic about MTG's growth trajectory, driven by new business, solid persistency, and a declining trend in claim filings, coupled with robust capital management and share repurchase programs.
Dec 24, 2025 • MarketBeat
NEUTRAL
Voya Investment Management LLC Sells 253,681 Shares of MGIC Investment Corporation $MTG
Voya Investment Management LLC significantly reduced its stake in MGIC Investment Corporation (NYSE:MTG) during the third quarter, selling 253,681 shares to now own 351,816 shares valued at approximately $9.98 million. This comes after MGIC reported Q3 earnings of $0.83 EPS, beating consensus, and maintaining a $0.15 quarterly dividend. The article also highlights recent insider selling by the CEO and EVP, contrasting with the substantial institutional ownership of the company.
Dec 23, 2025 • Simply Wall Street
SOMEWHAT-BULLISH
MGIC Investment (MTG): Reassessing Valuation After Earnings Beat and Upward Analyst Revisions
MGIC Investment (MTG) has seen increased investor attention following an earnings beat, though revenue slightly missed forecasts. Despite trading above most analyst targets, the stock is at a discount to some intrinsic value estimates, raising questions about whether it is undervalued or if its future growth is already priced in. There are differing valuation perspectives, with one narrative suggesting a 7.2% overvaluation at $29.66 compared to a fair value of $27.67, while an earnings ratio analysis suggests the stock is good value.
Dec 22, 2025 • Yahoo Finance
NEUTRAL
MGIC Investment (MTG) Valuation Check After EPS Beat and Upgraded Analyst Outlook
MGIC Investment (MTG) shares have risen after an EPS beat and positive analyst outlook, prompting questions about its valuation. Analysts have a consensus price target of $27.333, implying it's overvalued at its current price of $29.63, while a market multiple comparison suggests it may be cheap. Investors are encouraged to consider these differing views and potential risks.
Dec 22, 2025 • Simply Wall Street
SOMEWHAT-BULLISH
Does Board Exit Amid Earnings Beat Reveal Anything New About MGIC Investment’s Risk Culture (MTG)?
MGIC Investment (MTG) recently announced a board resignation which the company stated was unrelated to any disagreements. This news follows a strong earnings report for MGIC, where profits exceeded expectations. The article suggests that this governance change is likely immaterial to the company's core investment thesis, with focus remaining on credit performance, capital returns, and potential delinquency risks.
Dec 21, 2025 • Simply Wall Street
BULLISH
Has MGIC Investment’s Strong Multi Year Rally Already Priced In Its Earnings Power?
MGIC Investment has seen significant stock appreciation over multiple years, driven by a stable US housing market and improved sentiment for mortgage insurers. Despite its strong rally, the company appears undervalued based on Excess Returns Analysis and Price-to-Earnings ratios when compared to industry averages and its specific growth outlook. Investors are encouraged to consider different narratives for MGIC's future to determine its true worth.